Blog Layout

Ground source heat pumps: horizontal collectors Vs. vertical boreholes

Doug Johnson • 11 August 2020

In this post, we explain the benefits and key practical differences between the two most popular types of collector for ground source heat pumps.


Horizontal collectors or vertical boreholes?

Initial Disruption


Most of us understand that horizontal collectors require quite a bit of land to install; this is necessary to ensure correct spacing of collector pipes to maximise their efficiency. The pipes are often installed approximately 1.5m below ground level; usually in trenches spaced equally apart. To really maximise efficiency and safety, a large bulk excavation is undertaken and the pipe laid out like underfloor heating, ensuring an even distribution of heat is extracted. This kind of excavation requires big machines, time and space.


Many people are not aware that the collector area, once installed, will no longer be available for future tree planting, pond construction, driveways or any other construction as it has to be left porous and free from potential root damage. This can limit its application.


Boreholes too require a bit of mess at the start, and there is initial disruption with the physical installation i.e. drilling rig and other plant. However, when installed, the boreholes can be positioned under buildings, drives etc. and will take up far less space than horizontal collectors. Boreholes are often only 6” in diameter and have a small inspection chamber at the top of the hole. 

Ground source vs borehole

Local Geology


Geology and ground conditions must be considered for both types of collector. Generally, the best areas for horizontal collectors are saturated or wetter areas of the site; to give the best long-term heat recovery and ensure lasting efficiency for years to come. Saturation is key to the horizontal collectors performing at their best. In our experience, the temperature within the collectors buried at 1.5m would fluctuate between 8ºC (cold winter) 14ºC (hot summer) at 1.5m depth, depending on seasonal fluctuations. As you go deeper into the ground, the temperature of the ground becomes much more stable and this is where boreholes come into their own.


Depending on the geology found on site, the temperature at 100m deep would remain at approximately 12ºC all year round, unaffected by seasonal changes. At these depths, the collector is well into the permanent water table level and would remain saturated all year round increasing conductivity too.


System Lifespan


Regarding the physical installation, i.e. pipework, provided that the correct materials are used for the installation and fusion welded, both ground loop and borehole systems should have a similar expected lifespan. It is anticipated that both systems would be in excess of 50 years, theoretically longer as there should be very little degradation to the plastics used as they are not exposed to sunlight.  Both systems would require the glycol (heat transfer fluid) to be changed periodically.


It is imperative that there are no mechanical connections underground which cannot be mapped and ultimately be reached if necessary. Best practice would minimise joints in the system as far as is possible.


The collector system should always be checked annually when the heat pump is serviced to ensure that all of the collector loops are working correctly.


Money, Money, Money


A true cost comparison should be made between the systems after full design. However, horizontal collectors are typically cheaper than boreholes as specialist drilling equipment is not required.  This can vary between a 0% – 30% reduction in cost depending on some of the following factors.


  • Poor local geology: requiring a larger collector field than normal
  • Protection for the horizontal collector against sharp stones or other underground features
  • Time spent excavating the trenches
  • Landscaping: levelling, reseeding and revisiting this after the trenches have settled
  • For horizontal collectors, ground reinstatement could be considerable depending on the finished specification for landscaping


Generally, for a single vertical borehole, costs are around £10,000 (due to high initial equipment mobilisation costs) but for multiple boreholes that cost can drop to nearer £6,000 per borehole.


If you dig trenches to put horizontal collectors in, costs work out to be around half that of doing a bulk excavation, so it is important to understand your overall strategy to nail down the project costs and stay within budget!

Cost comparison

System Efficiency


Even in a perfectly designed ground collector system, their relative proximity to the surface means that there is potential for seasonal changes in ground temperature, and slightly increased heat pump inefficiency during winter.  And the same effect can happen in summer if you are cooling a building; when using the warm ground to cool water to be used in the building for active cooling.


Boreholes conversely benefit from far greater depths and the water table and are not affected by the same fluctuations that horizontal loops are. As a result, it enables your heat pump system in a cold winter to be running at the same efficiency as in warmer weather.  When cooling, this is particularly beneficial and, as a result, boreholes are often used in office complex installations because of this superior cooling property.


Each collector type has its pros and cons. The best solution for your build will depend on cost, local geology, and bespoke technical requirements. Either way, you will be pleased to hear that the expertise for design and installation in this complex area is close at hand.


If you still have any questions about ground source heat pumps, or anything else to do with your low-energy home,
please don't hesitate to
contact the Mesh team today.

SHARE THIS POST WITH YOUR NETWORK

by Doug Johnson 24 March 2025
Mesh Team Blasts Half Marathon for Cancer Charities
by Doug Johnson 24 March 2025
Offsite housing specialists TALO and building performance consultants Mesh Energy have announced a collaboration agreement to accelerate the delivery of ultra-low energy homes. The collaboration will combine TALO’s advanced timber superstructure technology from Finland with Mesh’s experience of providing net zero building performance and engineering services for housebuilders, architects and residential property developers. Working closely together, TALO and Mesh will aim to significantly increase the energy efficiency of new homes for market sale, rent and affordable housing, exceeding both Passivhaus energy standards and Future Homes standards, in compliance with the latest regulations. Doug Johnson, Director of Mesh Energy: “TALO’s timber superstructure solutions for low rise housing are the very best we have seen in the UK in terms of energy efficiency, air tightness, cost and quality. Their latest projects are achieving at least a 30 per cent improvement on Passivhaus energy standards and at no cost premium. We don’t believe there is anything like this on the market today and yet it is very needed. Some of the biggest issues facing housebuilders and developers are managing risk and addressing skills shortages. TALO’s system addresses both of these challenges extremely well. New regulation is coming which will make it increasingly difficult for developers to balance the rising cost of building new homes to the required energy and air tightness standards and the risk of non-compliance. New homes simply need to perform better. And yet the risk for developers is in the fabric and performance of each home. Our new collaboration will give housebuilders the benefit of much greater certainty of delivery to the required quality, air tightness and energy standards from the inception of a project. Our work on the energy strategy, data and compliance will support TALO’s extremely efficient way of building new homes to reduce risk for residential property developers.” TALO and Mesh have already collaborated on a number of projects. Under the new agreement, both businesses can leverage their respective experience to enhance the efficiency and economics of new residential projects. Dr Anthony Greer, Corporate Strategy Director of TALO said: "Our vision is to transform UK housebuilding by taking proven technology which has been used to build thousands of units in the Nordics – in one of the most extreme climates in the world. Our goal is to address some of the difficult problems that have been challenging the UK construction industry for many years – skills shortages, speed of delivery, sub-standard quality, and poor energy efficiency. Our ultimate goal is the offsite construction of high quality, ultra-low energy homes that can eradicate fuel poverty and snagging. By radically reducing time on site, developers can achieve a faster return on investment. They need fewer trades on site because we are using highly efficient offsite technology. Our processes are entirely dry – from forest to site – which means better air tightness performance and more accurate programme scheduling for the fitout phase to further reduce risk. Homes built by TALO exceed Passivhaus energy and air tightness standards at no cost impediment. This means homeowners and tenants will have hugely reduced energy costs that are verified by A-rated EPC certifications. Our housebuilding solutions will be enhanced with our collaboration with Mesh, helping to solve the technical and economic challenges that are constraining the sector and compounding the housing and cost of living crises.” In the new arrangement, Mesh will provide the energy strategy, data analysis and compliance work to support TALO’s delivery of the offsite superstructures for low-rise housing projects – which range from terraced housing, semi-detached family homes and larger executive schemes for developers and housebuilders across the UK.
by Pablo Jiménez-Moreno 29 April 2024
Discover the critical role of a feasibility study in integrating renewable technologies into your home. Learn how to make informed decisions for sustainable living.
by Doug Johnson 11 January 2024
As we come out of our end of year hibernation period for 2023 and try to both digest and interpret what 2023 had in store for us, how we dealt with it, and what we would change if we could; we drag ourselves out into the blinding light of 2024 and hope for a less tumultuous year in the UK’s sustainable construction sector. I am an optimistic person and ‘glass half-full thinking’, as well as doing my best to gaze into the future, is my default position. When working with a team on the sharp end of sustainable building design, there are some trends which simply cannot be ignored and hold great promise for 2024. The following trends are in areas we’ve seen growing design time and client fees being spent to great effect, and that’s why these are my top four sustainable construction prediction of 2024.
by Doug Johnson 7 December 2023
In recent years, sustainability has seen a massive increase in priority within the construction industry. As climate change and its effects worsen around the world, architects, builders, and developers are now feeling more compelled to adopt more environmentally friendly practices. While pursuing sustainable building design is definitely a commendable course of action, the process itself has its own set of challenges; introducing potential risks to the construction industry that must be addressed.
by Rebecca Boehme 3 August 2023
In May 2023, we discovered we’d been included in The Sunday Times’ ‘Best Places to Work in 2023’ list . This phenomenal achievement was the icing on the cake of what’s been a great few years for Mesh as an employer. From achieving our B Corp in November 2021, to being recognised in B Corp’s ‘Best in the World’ category for workers in March 2022, to growing the business to the 22-strong team it is today, it’s been both incredible to see our recognition grow, and a mammoth effort to get here.
by Doug Johnson 27 July 2023
Incorporating low-energy solutions like solar PV, battery systems, and other energy-efficient technologies into commercial buildings offers several key benefits. We cover the top 5 in our latest blog.
by Doug Johnson 20 July 2023
In this second blog on the technology behind low-energy commercial projects, I'll be exploring why solar PV, energy storage, EV charging systems, and LED lighting are crucial assets to any low-energy commercial building.
by Doug Johnson 13 July 2023
It's estimated that commercial buildings contribute around 8% of the UK's total annual carbon emissions, and carbon associated with heating, ventilating, and cooling buildings makes up about 40% of a building's total annual energy usage.
by Lewis Caudy 5 July 2023
When it comes to sustainable and energy-efficient building design, architects are increasingly turning to geothermal technology as a viable option.
More posts

Subsribe to memo from mesh

Share by: